Free payroll software for small business does exist, but only a handful of tools let you run payroll at no cost, and almost none of them deposit and file your payroll taxes for you. In the US right now, the genuinely free picks are Payroll4Free (if you pay 9 or fewer people no more than once a month), HR.my and spreadsheet-style tools. Full-service payroll that handles the IRS for you starts around $35 a month plus a few dollars per person.
So the real question isn’t “what’s free?” It’s “which part of payroll am I willing to own myself?”
Merchant Maverick’s walkthrough above is a good look at how these free tools actually feel to use. It was recorded a few years ago, so treat the prices in it as history. Every price in this article was checked on the vendor’s own site on November 17, 2026.
Here’s my view, and it’s the reason I wrote this. The subscription is the cheapest part of payroll. The expensive part is a late tax deposit. Save $50 a month on software, miss one deposit by a couple of weeks, and the IRS penalty can wipe out a year of savings in a single letter. Free payroll is a great deal for the right business. For the wrong one, it’s the most expensive “free” thing you’ll ever sign up for.
What “Free Payroll Software” Actually Means
When you search for free payroll software, you get four very different things sold under the same word:
Type of “free”
What you actually get
Examples
Genuinely free
Run payroll at no cost, indefinitely, but you handle tax deposits and filings
Payroll4Free (within its limits), HR.my
Free core, paid extras
Calculations are free; tax filing or the vendor’s direct deposit costs extra
Payroll4Free’s optional tax and deposit services
Free trial or promo
The full product for 30 days or a discount for a few months, then the normal price
Patriot, plus most big brands
Free calculator
One paycheck calculated at a time, nothing saved, nothing filed
Online paycheck calculators
Only the first row is what most owners mean when they type “free.” Everything else is a sales funnel, which is fine, as long as you know you’re in one.
The Best Free Payroll Software Options (Checked November 2026)
1. Payroll4Free
This is the one most people land on, and for good reason. According to its FAQ, the basic service is free as long as you pay 9 or fewer people no more than once a month. That includes payroll processing, tax calculations, vacation tracking, reports and direct deposit through your own bank (or paper checks). You can pay W-2 employees, 1099 contractors or both.
How is it free? The company says advertisers pay to show small ads inside the software. The catches: depositing and filing your taxes for you is a paid add-on, so is using its bank for direct deposit, and the software needs Windows (Mac users have to run Windows). Pay weekly or every two weeks and you’re outside the free limits.
2. HR.my
HR.my says it’s free forever for unlimited employees, funded by its user community instead of paid plans. It bundles payroll with leave tracking, a time clock and expense claims. It’s built for a global audience, and FirstHR’s comparison notes that it doesn’t ship with US federal and state tax tables, so you’d be entering withholding yourself. That’s a lot of trust to put in your own math.
3. ExcelPayroll
If you live in spreadsheets, this free Excel workbook runs payroll offline for up to 50 employees. Per Indeed’s 2026 roundup, state tax tables cost extra ($50 to $100 depending on the state) and there’s no direct deposit. Your data never leaves your computer, which some owners love.
4. Square Payroll for contractors only (nearly free)
Not free, but close if you only pay 1099 contractors. Square’s pricing page lists its contractor-only plan at $6 per month per person paid, with no base fee. Pay two contractors and you’re at $12 a month.
What Free Payroll Software Won’t Do for You
This is the part the “best free” lists skip. Free tools calculate. You still have to do the government’s paperwork, on time, every time. For most employers that means:
- Depositing federal payroll taxes (withheld income tax plus both halves of Social Security and Medicare) on a monthly or semi-weekly schedule. The Treasury’s EFTPS system is free for businesses to use.
- Filing Form 941 every quarter and Form 940 for federal unemployment once a year, per the IRS employment tax due dates page.
- Sending W-2s to employees and the Social Security Administration by January 31, and 1099-NECs to contractors.
- State withholding, state unemployment and new-hire reporting, which vary by state.
Miss a deposit and the IRS failure to deposit penalty kicks in: 2% if you’re 1 to 5 days late, 5% at 6 to 15 days, 10% after 15 days, and 15% if it drags past an IRS notice. Interest gets added on top.
Cheapest Paid Payroll When Free Stops Making Sense
Here are the standard list prices I found on each vendor’s pricing page on November 17, 2026. Intro promos are left out because they expire.
Provider and plan
Monthly price
Files and pays taxes for you?
Patriot Basic Payroll
$17 + $4 per worker
No (you file)
Patriot Full Service Payroll
$37 + $5 per worker
Yes
Square Payroll (full service)
$35 + $6 per person paid
Yes
Wave Payroll (US)
$40 + $6 per active employee or contractor
Yes, in all 50 states
Gusto Simple
$49 + $6 per person
Yes
Sources: Patriot, Square, Wave and Gusto. Prices change, so check before you sign.
Free vs Paid Payroll: A Worked Example
Take a small landscaping business with four employees paid every two weeks. These are example numbers, not a quote.
- Payroll4Free: doesn’t fit. Biweekly pay breaks the “no more than once monthly” rule.
- Patriot Full Service: $37 + (4 x $5) = $57 a month, or $684 a year, taxes handled.
- Gusto Simple: $49 + (4 x $6) = $73 a month, or $876 a year, taxes handled.
Now the other side. Say one month’s federal deposit is $6,000 and it goes in 16 days late because you were on a job site and forgot. That’s a 10% penalty: $600, plus interest. One slip costs close to a full year of full-service payroll. That’s why I think most businesses with regular employees should pay for tax filing, and save “free” for very small, very simple payrolls.
When Free Payroll Makes Sense (and When to Pay)
Free payroll software is a smart move when:
- You pay a few people once a month, in one state.
- You (or your bookkeeper) actually enjoy the admin and keep a deadline calendar.
- You mostly pay contractors and just need clean records and 1099s.
- Your business is pre-revenue and every dollar matters for the next few months.
Pay for full service when:
- You pay weekly or biweekly, or you have more than a handful of people.
- You have employees in more than one state.
- Your time is worth more than $50 a month (it is).
- You’ve already missed a deadline once. Don’t wait for the second.
How to Run Payroll for Free Without Getting Burned
- Get your IDs in order. An EIN from the IRS, plus your state withholding and unemployment accounts.
- Classify every worker correctly. Get the employee vs contractor call wrong and free software just helps you make the mistake faster. My breakdown of W-2 vs 1099 walks through the tests.
- Collect W-4s and I-9s before the first paycheck.
- Pick a pay schedule that fits your tool. On Payroll4Free that means monthly.
- Enroll in EFTPS right away. Enrollment takes time and you need it before your first deposit.
- Put every deadline in your calendar for the year: deposits, 941s, 940, W-2s.
- Reconcile each payroll against your bank account the same week you run it.
- Review once a year. If you’ve grown past the free limits, switch at the start of a quarter so your filings stay clean.
One more thing for owners of S corps: you’re on payroll too. If you’re still working out the right salary versus distributions, read my guide on how to pay yourself as a business owner before you set up your own paycheck.
This is general information, not tax advice. Payroll rules vary by state, so run your setup past a CPA or enrolled agent.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there truly free payroll software for small business?
Yes, but it’s limited. Payroll4Free is free if you pay 9 or fewer people no more than monthly, and HR.my is free for unlimited employees. Neither files and pays your payroll taxes for free.
Can I do payroll myself for free?
Yes. You can calculate pay with a free tool, deposit taxes through the Treasury’s free EFTPS system and file Forms 941, 940 and W-2s yourself. It costs nothing but time and attention to deadlines.
Is Gusto free?
No. As of November 2026, Gusto’s cheapest payroll plan, Simple, is $49 a month plus $6 per person, and it includes tax filings and payments.
What is the cheapest payroll service for one employee?
Among full-service options checked in November 2026, Square Payroll works out to $41 a month for one person ($35 + $6) and Patriot Full Service to $42 ($37 + $5). Payroll4Free is $0 if you pay monthly and file taxes yourself.
Do I need payroll software to pay 1099 contractors?
No. Contractors don’t get tax withheld, so you can pay them directly. Software just makes tracking and issuing 1099-NECs at year end easier.
What happens if I make a payroll tax deposit late?
The IRS charges a failure to deposit penalty of 2% to 15% of the late amount, depending on how late it is, plus interest. It can be removed if you show reasonable cause.
Disclaimer: Addicted2Success content is for general informational purposes only and is not a substitute for personalized advice from a qualified, licensed professional. Always seek professional counsel for your specific situation before making decisions.

