If you’re between 45 and 75, Social Security likely plays a big role in your retirement
plan. But even those already collecting benefits often misunderstand how the
program truly works.
The confusion isn’t surprising. With a maze of rules (and exceptions) that
govern filing age, taxes, COLAs, and survivorship, Social Security can get
complicated fast.
Below are 10 common things retirees get wrong, and what the Social Security
Administration (SSA) actually says.
Social Security benefits are not taxed
Many retirees assume that Social Security benefits are tax-free. They’re not.
If you file as an individual and your combined income exceeds $25,000, or if you
file jointly and your combined income exceeds $32,000, you may owe federal taxes
on a portion of your benefits.
Shopping for cheaper auto insurance? Enter your zip code here to get started.
Everyone gets the same maximum benefit
You may have seen headlines about “the maximum Social Security benefit.” But
there’s no one single number.
In 2026, someone receiving the maximum benefit could receive up to $4,152 per
month if claiming at full retirement age. If you claim earlier, that amount
drops to $2,969. And inversely, if you wait until age 70, the maximum rises to
$5,181.
Most people, however, will not qualify for the full maximum amount at any age
tier. Your benefit depends on your earnings history and retirement age.
You must apply in person for Social Security benefits
Some retirees believe they must file in person.
In early 2025, the Trump administration proposed an in-person enrollment
requirement in its effort to combat fraud and corruption. Ultimately, President
Trump walked back the proposed measure days before it was set to go into effect. Although the Trump administration did make other changes to Social Security this year.
Participants can enroll remotely. The SSA says using its online application is
the easiest and most convenient way to apply, although telephone or in-person
appointments are still available.
You can claim survivor benefits online
Unlike retirement benefits, you must call Social Security or contact your local
office to apply for survivor benefits.
Eligible survivors may include a spouse, divorced spouse, unmarried child, or
dependent parent.
There is also a one-time $255 lump sum death payment for qualifying survivors.
There is a two-year window in which to claim the $255 payout, which,
incidentally, has not been increased since 1954.
Social Security will call and demand immediate payment
Scammers often pose — quite convincingly – as Social Security agents to demand
payment by phone. The scam works because the SSA has made overpayments before,
and it does request excess funds be repaid.
Such overpayments are fairly common due to income changes, benefit
miscalculations, eligibility updates, or administrative errors – thus, repayment
demands may sound believable even when fraudulent.
The SSA will never threaten you with arrest, suspend your Social Security
number, demand immediate payment, or require payment by gift card, wire
transfer, or cash. Rather, they will send you an overpayment notice and allow
you to appeal it.
Your COLA increase notice comes in the mail
Many retirees assume they need to wait for a mailed notice to learn about their
annual cost-of-living adjustment (COLA).
For 2026, benefits were increased by 2.8%. This year, most beneficiaries were able to view their COLA notice by early December through their online my Social Security
account — if it was created by November 19, 2025.
Retirement News: Almost 80% of Americans fear a retirement age increase — here’s the real reason why
In-person appointments are the only way to get help
Some retirees think they must schedule an in-person appointment for any issue.
Many services, however, can be handled online, including applying for benefits,
checking application status, estimating future benefits, and managing current
benefits.
If you do need an appointment, you can schedule, reschedule, or cancel by phone.
Social Security only contacts you by mail
It’s true that Social Security typically sends letters if there’s an update or
issue with your account. But for certain situations, the agency may call you.
According to the SSA, they may call you if you recently applied for benefits,
are receiving payments and they need to update or verify records, or if you
specifically requested a phone call.
Knowing this can help you separate legitimate contact from scams.
If you’re old enough, you can apply whenever you want
Timing matters more than many retirees realize.
You can apply for retirement benefits up to four months before you want payments
to begin. The SSA recommends signing up a few months before you want benefits to
begin to avoid potential income gaps.
If you’re waiting until age 70 to claim Social Security, you should still apply
a few months early and designate the future month you want benefits to begin.
You can claim back-owed benefits if you claim late, but Social Security will
only pay a maximum of six months of retroactive benefits.
You can’t have taxes withheld from Social Security
Some retirees assume that if their benefits are taxable, the government will
automatically withhold federal income taxes from their monthly checks. That’s
not how it works.
Unlike job wages, Social Security benefits are not automatically subject to
federal withholding. If you expect to owe taxes, you can proactively request
voluntary withholding from the SSA.
You can choose to have 7%, 10%, 12%, or 22% withheld from your monthly benefit
by submitting Form W-4V or updating your preferences through your my Social
Security account.
If you don’t elect withholding, you may need to make quarterly estimated tax
payments instead.
Bottom line
Social Security rules are more nuanced than most retirees expect. Taxes, timing,
survivor rules, COLAs, and maximum benefits all come with caveats and fine print
that can materially affect your income.
Before filing or making changes, take time to review the official SSA guidance
and double-check how the rules apply to your specific situation.
You can find other free and helpful resources, such as the National Council on
Aging, AARP, or your local senior center. A clearer understanding today can help you avoid costly
mistakes tomorrow.
Subscribe Today
Unlock the Best Banking Deals and Bonuses
From high-yield savings accounts to cashback checking and sign-up bonuses, we bring you the best banking offers to grow your money smarter.
Author Details
Chris Lewis, CEPF
Chris Lewis has spent his career turning data into answers. As Director of Digital PR at FinanceBuzz and a Certified Educator in Personal Finance, he oversees the data journalism and media relations teams, digging into the personal finance topics that shape Americans’ lives at every stage, from Social Security and retirement income to 401(k) strategies, jobs, and real estate.
