Why people in the “community” avoid the word well-being
I am a Yamabushi,
a journaling guide,
a bodyworker,
and I have been practicing yoga and meditation for over 20 years.
So, I am definitely what you would call a person in the “well-being” community.
However, I try not to use this word very much.
Or rather, I feel it is a word I want to avoid as much as possible.
Well-being was originally a term used to define “health” in the World Health Organization (WHO) constitution (adopted in 1946). It is not just the absence of disease or infirmity, but a state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being.
It is a wonderful thing, and I want to be that way. I myself work while hoping that all my activities will head in “this direction.”
But.
I wonder why.
The moment I put it into words, I feel like it becomes something “else”.
Is well-being something to “aim for”?
“Let’s aim for well-being”
is what we have started to be told.
Furthermore, even in the business books I used to work with,
“well-being management”
has started to be talked about.
I understand that they are not saying anything bad.
But I wonder if I am the only one who feels a certain discomfort with these words, or to put it more bluntly, feels they are “fishy”.
The reason for this is likely not the word itself, but how it is used.
More specifically, I feel uncomfortable with the fact that “purpose” and “means” have been swapped.
Just like “health” or “happiness,” well-being inherently has no end.
Even so, the very act of heading in that direction and trying to get even a little closer helps align us into a “good state”.
“Well-being” is originally something that gives us a “vector” or “direction”, isn’t it?
“Heading toward” and “aiming for” seem similar but are different, I think.
Heading toward is a direction, and aiming for is a destination.
The moment well-being becomes something to “aim for,” a destination is created.
And once a destination is created, judgment based on that destination begins.
Am I in a good state right now?
Am I in a bad state?
How far have I progressed toward the destination/goal?
This judgment is the tricky part.
Actually, truth be told, I have a past where I fell into that trap and struggled many times myself.
Let me write a little bit about that dark history.
The day “meditation” changed from something I “had to do” to something I “wanted to do”
I wrote at the beginning that I have been practicing meditation for over 20 years, but most of that history is one of “struggle.”
The reason I started meditation was my encounter with transpersonal psychology and integral theory.
Humans are beings who can grow indefinitely.
Even to the point of what is called “enlightenment.”
That view of humanity was exciting to me when I was a university student, and I believe it still supports the foundation of how I live my life today.
I don’t know if I can reach enlightenment.
But, I want to open up my potential as much as possible.
Meditation was what I encountered as a methodology for that.
However, as you will realize when you try it, meditation is quite difficult.
While there are pleasant moments,
there are also times when you are swallowed by a storm of boring thoughts and just have to endure.
Even so, no matter what I learn, I end up back at meditation.
It seems I can’t escape it no matter how far I go.
So, in a sense, I have continued it because I “had no choice.”
Come to think of it, I had placed the goal of “opening up my potential” beyond meditation.
Meditation was something I “had to do” to get there.
I would do it, fail, and start again.
When over 10 years had passed repeating that,
“This time, I will face it properly.”
Thinking that, I participated in a Vipassana meditation retreat.
I handed over my smartphone, didn’t speak to anyone, and sat intently for 10 days.
After a few days passed, a pleasant sensation of my body melting away and becoming one with something greater began to come back again and again.
It feels good.
I want to stay immersed in this forever.
However, as the Buddha taught, everything is “impermanent.”
No matter how pleasant a sensation is, it will not last forever.
And meditation was originally a practice to cultivate an “observing self” that continues to observe the reality that flows in that way.
Nevertheless, I had started sitting while seeking only “special sensations.”
In the place where I was supposed to have come to “face it properly,” I was chasing yet another goal.
When a sensation came, it was a “good meditation.”
When it didn’t come, it was a “bad meditation.”
Before I knew it, I had started making judgments about every sitting.
When it came, I was happy.
When it didn’t come, I was miserable.
In the end, I even felt despair, and
with only one day left in the retreat,
“I want to go home already!!!!”
I felt that from the bottom of my heart.
Even in the midst of such despair, while I was continuing to meditate, I suddenly realized something.
Meditation is not something you do to gain something.
The act of meditating itself is the goal.
Nothing dramatic is happening.
But when I was able to think that way, I felt like I had finally reached the entrance to meditation.
From that moment on, for me,meditation changed from something I ‘had to do’ to something I ‘wanted to do’.And I no longer felt embarrassed to say, ‘I am meditating.’
I still continue to meditate today, but that experience has become an important foundation for me.
* * *
Dr. Jon Kabat-Zinn, Professor Emeritus at the University of Massachusetts Medical School, who developed Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR), also writes about this repeatedly in his book, ‘Meditation Is Not What You Think’.
There is no ‘good state’ or ‘bad state’ in meditation.
Whether it is good or bad, no matter what happens, you just stay there and keep observing., he says.
By the way, the bodywork I practice, called Craniosacral Biodynamics, is even more extreme.
You let go of even the intention to do something and focus entirely on observation.
At that moment, the power that people inherently possess to move toward health begins to work., it suggests.
Stop aiming for a good state.
And accept yourself as you are now.
At that moment, the next step will open up.
It might be a little similar to ‘the more you try to sleep, the less you can sleep’.
Like a mirage, it may be something that moves further away the more you aim for it and try to get closer.
Because I know this from personal experience, I find myself wanting to keep some distance from the current buzzword-driven ‘well-being industry’.
And, as someone within that circle, I dare to say this.
Things that move away when you ‘aim’ for them.
Perhaps that is what well-being is.
In order not to let ‘well-being’ become a thought-terminating cliché
However, that said.
I apologize for saying such arrogant things, but I am by no means a pure and innocent person.
To confess, I have a past of selling the dream of ‘becoming a better state’.
Back when I was making books at a publishing house, I was one of the first to plan a mindfulness book for business.
The title of the book I was in charge of was ‘How to Train Concentration, Practiced by the World’s Top Elites’.
‘The world’s top elites are already doing it. If you don’t do it too, you’ll be left behind.’—Because mindfulness is important, I wanted people to turn their attention to it. That is why I dared to put out such a message.
I, who sold meditation for the sake of ‘results’,
suffered in 10 days of silence because of my own desire for results.
Isn’t that quite ironic?
Even so, I have no regrets about including that message in that book. If even a few people turned their eyes toward “this side” because of that book, I think that is a good thing.
(As an aside. I also thought I shouldn’t just leave it at that, so I continue to create small spaces for mindfulness practice even now ↓)
What I used at that time was the anxiety of being “left behind.”
However, the word well-being is even more powerful than that.
It is not anxiety, but rather something that carries a “good” that no one can deny because of that.
Having been on the side that creates trends, I understand.
“Arguments that no one can deny” or “goodness” are quite formidable.
In fact, there is almost no one who does not desire well-being. That is precisely why when you are told it is “for the sake of well-being,” there may be no room left to examine whether it is truly necessary for you.
But originally, each of us has such large individual differences that it cannot be said unconditionally what puts us in a “good state.”
In my case, it was being a Yamabushi, meditation, and yoga, but this does not necessarily work for everyone.
Even alcohol is medicine in moderation, but poison if you drink too much.
In the end, the only way to know what is good is to try it with your own body and verify it.
However.
If it makes you skip “examining it for yourself,” then isn’t that just creating “thoughtlessness” rather than well-being?
“If you don’t achieve well-being, you’re in trouble.”
“If you achieve well-being, you will get such-and-such results.”
“If you do this, you will definitely achieve well-being.”
If you encounter words like these, I want you to be a little suspicious. Because it might be a message of “thoughtlessness” wearing the name of “well-being.”
Well-being is not something that gives you answers so easily.
Rather,
“What is well-being?”
continuing to ask that question and continuing to try things in your own way might be the path toward well-being itself.
—that is what I, walking along the path, think.
That is why I ask myself questions and accumulate time that is comfortable for me every day.
In the morning, I have a time for prayer.
In the morning, I guide a space for writing meditation (mindfulness).
Once a month, I go into the mountains.
To maintain a body that can keep going into the mountains, I walk, run, do muscle training, and do yoga on a daily basis.
When I suddenly feel like I “want to do it,” I meditate (and as a result, I end up doing it almost every day).
Everything is modest, and there is nothing special.
There are good days, and there are days that are not.
Even so, I observe and accept myself for that day, and start the next day again.
First, accept what happens (in the teachings of the Yamabushi, this is called “Uketamo”).
Pause a little when faced with words being sold to you.
That is my own way of approaching well-being right now.
Of course, this is just my own personal yardstick that I have tested and verified with my own body, so it may not necessarily apply to you as it is.
So, in closing, I would like to ask you a little something.
What does a “good state” feel like to you?
When you are doing what, or when you are with whom, do you feel “mentally, physically, and socially fulfilled”?
What kind of “yardstick” do you have for yourself?
It is probably not something you can clearly put into words.
But I think that is perfectly fine.
Keep asking yourself.
Keep verifying it through your own body.
I just want you to hold onto those reins yourself, without handing them over to anyone else.
On the left is me. On the right is my partner. This was taken when we visited Tsumagoi Village a while ago. Whether we go somewhere or nowhere at all, well-being is right here, right now.
#WhatIsWellBeing

