Over the past couple of years, several legislative proposals have been introduced that would help extend Social Security payments. Some ideas have included raising the retirement age, collecting more Social Security funds through payroll taxes and even taxing higher earners’ benefits. The most recent one? A yearly benefit cap on both married and individual benefits. Below, we share everything you need to know about this proposal, including when it could take effect and what experts are warning might happen if it’s approved.
Social Security Taxes Could Vanish: You Earn It You Keep It Act Details
What to know about the new proposed Social Security cap
In March 2025, the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB) announced its “Six Figure Limit” plan, which would cap Social Security benefits at $100,000 per year for couples and $50,000 per year for individuals. This would be a big adjustment from the $184,500 cap Americans are currently experiencing in 2026.
The CRFB believes that lowering the cap will extend Social Security’s longevity, which would ensure younger generations will still be able to claim the benefits they’re entitled to when the time comes.
“The wealthiest seniors are collecting from Social Security for the first time $100,000 in benefits,” Marc Goldwein, senior policy director at the CRFB, told CBS News. “This is a program that, when you go back to its founding, was a measure of protection against falling into poverty. The fact that an income support program would pay six figures is a little silly.”
Currently, it’s believed that less than 2 percent of the 56 million people 65 or older who receive Social Security would be affected by this cap, which means the proposal would not touch the other 98 percent of Social Security beneficiaries’ benefits. Even so, some experts are warning that with or without a cap, everyone’s monthly and yearly benefits are still at risk.
Getty
“Proposals that focus on capping Social Security don’t address the problem in front of Congress: ensuring every American gets every dollar they have earned,” Jenn Jones, AARP vice president for financial security and livable communities, said in a statement, per CNBC. “What’s worse, ideas like this risk becoming a backdoor to broader cuts.”
Other experts like Nancy Altman, president of Social Security Works, say that this proposal would hurt more people than it helps.
“It’s younger people who really would be hurt by that proposal, because gradually it would hit more and more people and go to lower and lower levels,” she told CNBC.
$4,000 Social Security Tax Break Proposed: What It Could Mean for You
When would the new proposed Social Security cap take effect?
If approved by Congress and the Social Security Administration, the CRFB’s Six-Figure Limit plan could take effect right away. However, as of April 2026, neither Congress nor the Social Security Administration has scheduled hearings or votes on this proposal, making immediate implementation unlikely
“An income security program designed to keep seniors out of poverty, designed to ensure an adequate level of retirement income, shouldn’t be paying six figures,” Goldwein told CNBC. “And it particularly shouldn’t be paying six figures when it can’t afford to pay most people their scheduled benefits.”
Getty
“At some point, you have to ask, is that the government’s responsibility to compensate you?” he continued. “I mostly hope that this reinvigorates the conversation. If people don’t like it, come up with your own plan.”
Ready for more? Subscribe to our YouTube channel for video podcasts, health tips and uplifting stories designed for women 40, 50, 60 and beyond.
For more Social Security content, keep scrolling!
SSI Changes Coming: What Social Security’s New ‘Improvements Team’ Means for Your Benefits
Gas Prices Could Impact Your 2027 Social Security COLA—Here’s What Experts Are Predicting
Why Medicare Is Deducted From Your Social Security—And How to Change It if You Want to
